What the nation promised the counties that keep its forests
The federal forest payment that funds our schools and roads has fallen three-quarters since 2001. Congress has authorized Secure Rural Schools only through fiscal 2026, which ends September 30, 2026. Here is why PILT can't make up the difference, and why the county can't easily make it up locally.
The promise dates to 1906. Counties couldn't tax the national forests inside their borders, so Congress began sharing what the forest earned: 10% of its receipts at first, then, in 1908, 25%, paid through the state for public schools and roads. The Forest Service made its case to taxpayers in a 1907 pamphlet: "Thus a county which is partly covered by a National Forest is better off than one which is not." (The Use of the National Forests, 1907.)
In 2000 Congress offered counties Secure Rural Schools as a guaranteed alternative to the old timber share, after harvests on the Gifford Pinchot collapsed in the early 1990s. From 2008 the law shrank the national pot 10% a year, then 5% a year from 2012, until the 2021 infrastructure law froze it at the 2017 level. It has also lapsed twice: in 2016 the county got only the old 25% share, and Congress never made it up. In 1988, before the collapse, the forest paid Skamania County and its schools about $11.4 million.
No Washington county gets a larger forest payment, and none relies on it more: Skamania's is 3.5 times its PILT, the widest gap in the state (fiscal 2025).
| Fiscal year | Paid |
|---|
Payments in Lieu of Taxes figures each county's payment two ways and pays the larger (31 U.S.C. 6903). Both are capped by population first. The A-side pays more per acre but subtracts the forest money the county got the year before. The B-side pays a small flat rate and subtracts nothing.
So when forest money was high, the A-side nearly vanished and the county fell back to the B-side minimum. When it fell, PILT rose, but only up to the ceiling. Skamania's 841,692 federal acres are worth about $3.0 million at the 2026 rate. The population ceiling holds the payment to about $1.98 million.
PILT can soften a lost forest payment. It can't replace one.
| Payment year | A-side | B-side | Paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | min($2.65M, $1.69M) − $1.66M = $28,811 | 841,705 × $0.45 = $378,767 | $378,510 (B-side) |
| 2025 | min($2.91M, $1.93M) − $1.22M = $703,086 | $420,846 | $702,657 (A-side) |
| 2026 | min($2.99M, $1.98M) − $0.42M = $1,553,849 | $429,263 | $1,552,697 (A-side) |
Figures from Interior's national PILT summaries for 2023, 2025 and 2026 (Schedule 2). In every year the ceiling, not the acreage, sets the top of the A-side. Formula notation follows the National Center for Public Lands Counties at NACo.
Without a public vote, Washington lets a county's regular levy grow at most 1% a year (less when inflation is lower), plus new construction. The cost of running the same services rises faster. Our property tax explainer walks through the lid.
Even assuming costs grow a conservative 3.5% a year, the gap reaches about $525,000 a year by 2035. Washington counties' own books show median cost growth of 5.1% a year from 2015 to 2024 (Skamania's own: 6.2%). To stand still next year, Skamania would need about $74 million of new construction, 1.75 times what it added in 2025, and more every year after.
In Interior's 2026 payment file, 189 of the roughly 2,280 local governments listed have federal acreage worth more than their population ceiling lets them collect. Together, the ceilings held them back about $1.37 billion in 2026.
Interior says the 2026 PILT increase was "driven largely by a 42.63 percent decrease in prior year timber deductions," from the lapse in Secure Rural Schools. Of the $107.6 million drop in deductions, only about $69 million, roughly 64 cents on the dollar, reached counties as higher PILT. Most of the rest went to places already paid on the formula's flat minimum, many of them held there by their population ceilings.
Skamania isn't a special case. Using Forest Service and Interior payment data for fiscal 2025, we found 29 counties where national forest covers at least 45% of the land, forest and PILT payments come to at least $100 per resident, Secure Rural Schools is more than half of that money, and the county takes Secure Rural Schools rather than the old 25% share. Skamania ranks 20th, at $250 per resident. The 29 stretch across ten states, from Alaska to Florida, and their members of Congress come from both parties.
Why it matters: these are the counties a lapse hits hardest. When Secure Rural Schools lapsed for fiscal 2024, their forest payments fell back to the old 25% share, from $58.5 million to $8.3 million, a drop of 86%, or about $145 per resident. The search-and-rescue and emergency money in Title III went to zero. At that year's PILT, only 2 of the 29 would still fit this profile without Secure Rural Schools, because forest money would no longer be most of their federal dollars. Congress reauthorized the program in December 2025, and the money arrived in 2026. The same thing happened in 2016, when these counties lost 90%, and 2016 was never made up.
The list depends on the year. With fiscal 2026 PILT, which rose after Secure Rural Schools lapsed, it shrinks to 15 counties. Oregon counties are understated, because BLM's O&C timber payments aren't in either dataset. Five counties sit close to a cutoff. House districts are those of the 119th Congress (2025–2026); California and Utah have new maps for the 2026 election. Party labels are as the House Clerk and the Senate print them. Download the county table (CSV).